Skip to main content

Special Topics in Calamity Physics (2006)

A murder mystery I waited a long time to read.

Finishing this book is fulfilling a promise I made fourteen years ago to somebody I haven’t spoken to in a decade.

This was an important book to my ex-girlfriend, who chose her online handle based on the main character. I bought a copy of the book and resolved to read it, and then proceeded not to do so for many, many years. (You might reasonably ask how a person who reads dozens of books a year couldn’t squeeze in one book beloved by their partner, and the lack of kindness and care displayed by my younger self is one of many reasons we are no longer together.)

I kept the book after she broke up with me, and it’s followed me around across multiple houses. I was resolved to one day read it, and I’ve finally done so.

Reading this book has been a long and slow ordeal – it’s taken multiple weeks to get through, and I didn’t really become engaged until the final third. (The back half of the book is also when most of the plot happens.)

I did enjoy the ending and the ambiguity it leaves. Blue van Meer graduates high school and goes out into the world, but we never find out what becomes of her friends, her father, or the criminal conspiracy. (At some point in the book, her father directly foreshadows this ending with a comment up about how Americans hate to read things with unresolved endings.)

I’m not going to reread it now, but I’m going to keep it on my shelf, and this strikes me as a book that might read differently once you know the ending.

The book is packed with literary references to remind us how well-read Blue and her father are, which I found more grating than gratifying. She also has an air of moral superiority that I found vaguely off-putting. I’m not sure I particularly like or care about her as a character.

I didn’t particularly enjoy this book until the ending, but I am glad to have finally read it.

Quotes and highlights

Chapter 21 “Deliverance”:

In the woods, with its endless procession of malnourished pines and lop-eared rhododendrons and wan gray rocks, time seemed to speed up and slow down without provocation. I fell into a strange lull as I lumbered along in the very back, staring for minutes at a time at Jade’s red kneesocks (hiked up over her jeans; some precaution against rattlesnakes), the thick brown roots caterpillaring through the trail, the splotches of fading gold light staining the ground. The seven of us seemed to be the only things alive for miles (apart from a few invisible birds and a gray squirrel skittering up a tree’s torso) and one couldn’t help but wonder if Hannah was right, if this experience she’d forced us into was, in fact, a gateway to something else, some brave new understanding of the world. Pines frothed, imitating the ocean. A bird fluttered up, up, swiftly, like an air bubble, to the sky.

Chapter 25 “Bleak House”:

She was waiting for me to protest, fall to my knees, moan, but I couldn’t. I sensed the impossibility of it. I remembered what Dad said once, that some people have all of life’s answers worked out the day they’re born and there’s no use trying to teach them anything new. “They’re closed for business even though, somewhat confusingly, their doors open at eleven, Monday through Friday,” Dad said. And the trying to change what they think, the attempt to explain, the hope they’ll come to see your side of things, it was exhausting, because it never made a dent and afterward you only ached unbearably.

Chapter 36 “Metamorphoses”:

The most incredible thing about goldfish, however, is their memory. Everyone pities them for only remembering their last three seconds, but in fact, to be so forcibly tied to the present—it’s a gift. They are free. No moping over missteps, slip-ups, faux pas or disturbing childhoods. No inner demons. Their closets are light filled and skeleton free. And what could be more exhilarating than seeing the world for the very first time, in all of its beauty, almost thirty thousand times a day? How glorious to know that your Golden Age wasn’t forty years ago when you still had all your hair, but only three seconds ago, and thus, very possibly it’s still going on, this very moment.” I counted three Mississippis in my head, though I might have rushed it, being nervous. “And this moment, too.” Another three seconds. “And this moment, too.” Another. “And this moment, too.

Chapter 36 “Metamorphoses” reminds me of how I am with my current partner:

I continued up the sidewalk, past Hanover and the lawn in front of the cafeteria littered with branches, and the Scratch, the rain turning it all to soup. And Zach, without “Wait,” or “Where are you—?” he stayed right there, right by my right shoulder without needing to chat about it. We walked without formula, hypothesis or detailed conclusion. His shoes moved cleanly through the rain, fishtail splashes in a pond, the fishes themselves mysteries—mine too. He held the umbrella a precise distance over my head. And I tested it—because Van Meers always had to test things—inching a little outside the shelter of it, imperceptibly to the right; I accelerated, slowed, paused to wipe more grass off my shoes, curious if I could get a small percentage of my knee or elbow, some part wet, but he held it over my head with remarkable consistency. By the time we reached the top of the stairs and the Volvo, and the trees crowding the road danced, but only very slightly—they were extras after all, not wanting to distract from the leads—not a new drop of rain had touched me.