Until the Last Light Goes out (2026)

A supernatural horror set in a hungry building, with shades of a sapphic romance.
This was a fun little horror novel, with more sci-fi and supernatural elements than I was expecting from the blurb.
A month ago, Paige’s best friend KJ went to Kaleidoscope Key, a resort that was abandoned 25 years ago after almost all the visiting students died in the course of a single night. Paige’s gone to find her, along with Caleb and Matteo, and the four of them are the children of the only survivors of the original massacre. Paige’s mother returned to the hotel when Paige was a child and died in mysterious circumstances; Paige doesn’t want the same fate to fall on KJ.
I was expecting a traditional murder mystery, but the resort has more supernatural elements. Rooms move, doors disappear, and ghosts can be found roaming the halls. (It vividly reminded me of the “Tesseract” episode of the TV show Black Hole High.)
The whole story has a fun non-linear nature, and events don’t always happen in the “right” order. While exploring the hotel, Paige has several encounters with her mother, who experiences their meetings coincident with the massacre 25 years prior. Or maybe it’s her mother’s ghost, trapped in an afterlife time loop? It’s not clear common, but I quite enjoy the ambiguity.
The book still “plays fair” – the building is capricious, but consistent. Everything unfolds in a sensible way, and there’s no deus ex machina or surprise twist at the ending.
The monster isn’t defeated by jargon or a grand plan, but with a classic trope: no one left behind. Paige’s decision not to abandon CJ and KJ in the hotel – the opposite of what happened between her mother and Summer Hayes 25 years prior – ultimately saves them both. It’s also a pleasant inversion of the usual formula where one half of lesbian couples always dies in horror stories.
I don’t think of myself as somebody interested in paranormal stories, but I absolutely raced through this one, and I’d happily read another book by this author.
Quotes and highlights
Page 313 (Casey is Paige’s late mother):
[Casey] hoped then that death would be a reprieve: a sweet, dark nothing to spirit her away from a never-ending cycle of torment.
But in death, she found herself floating back into that dark ocean beyond the island with pale headlights beaming over the water. The girl—her daughter—was there with her, and she was young and grown all at once. She was all the versions Casey would never get to see, and she was unbelievably beautiful.
And on page 339, the epilogue, after they’ve both escaped, with a remnant of the monster surviving inside KJ. The book starts as it ends, with narration from the monster inside the building.
“I still see it out there,” the dark-haired girl says.
“The island?”
She shakes her head. “The light.”
The blond nods, though she doesn’t see it anymore. Not since they washed ashore, and not in the weeks since. She supposes the moment her mother was released, the haunting ended for her. It is only the dark-haired girl who must carry the burden of it now.
It is the nature of a trade, though, and this trade allows them to stand here together. What can she do but cherish it?
Perhaps the dark-haired girl’s mother was right, and trading always leaves them with less than when they started. Both girls are certainly less now. Half of the dark-haired girl’s life is made up of the horrors that nearly killed them. One day, the hunger might eat away the rest of her. One day, the sea might call her and her monster home. One day, the finite life they traded for might come to an abrupt end.
But perhaps the other girl’s mother was right, too.
For all the evil in the world, there are moments like this. The girls standing before the sea, hands linked, breathing in the quiet. A possible life stretched out ahead of them that felt impossible only weeks ago. The only thing to do in the face of it all, the blond girl thinks, is find the person she loves most and hold on.
Maybe this life will come to an end, but until the moment it’s gone, she won’t be alone.
And I will be with them.